December 25, 2011

Interesting experience at an intersection

A recent experience at an intersection resulted in me wondering about law, human thought processes and the quality of our public service. These five tragi-comic minutes gave me a few answers but raised many more.

I stopped at a red light on a busy street. This being a rush hour, I was behind four or five vehicles in the right "lane". When the light changed to green, I started moving (inching) but could make only a few feet into the intersection when the amber came on. I was staring at a red pretty soon.

My understanding of the Indian traffic rules is that you can enter an intersection if the light is still green irrespective of whether you can make it to the other end within the available time. Once you enter the intersection, you gain priority over other drivers. You can then continue to drive even if the light changes.

Armed with this understanding, I continued to drive at 0 kph. A cop appeared out of thin air and asked me to stop. He asked for my driver license and pocketed it. I tried to explain but he would have none of it. Apparently they taught him a different set of rules. He pointed out that the bus on my left had stopped bang in the middle of the intersection (blocking traffic partially). He felt this was OK as there was enough room for the cross traffic to maneuver their way around.

Soon the light changed to green and the cop asked me to cross the intersection and pull over to the left. With all the traffic, this was not easy for me to do  as I had to cut across 3-4 "lanes", traffic turning left from the intersection and the other distractions you find. It was a good 100+ feet before I could reach a safe spot but there was already another car parked there. As the driver had left his hazard lights on, I assumed this was a fellow "violator". I crossed this car, switched on my own hazard lights and parked a dozen feet behind.

Mindful the cop had my license with him, I started walking back. Sure enough he had abandoned his post and was walking towards me. He explained to me that the challan would be mailed, returned my license and took out a trendy looking camera.

The cop proceeded to take pictures of the other car, not mine. The other driver returned around this time, smiled weakly and said he was leaving any moment now. The cop smiled back, said it was OK and returned to his position.

I started wondering how he could forgot which vehicle he ordered to pull over. The two vehicles differed on size, make, color and every conceivable parameter.

I grew up  with a healthy disrespect for policemen and this did not change much with years. I tend to agree when people around me say "khatmals" have "brains in knees". This incident did not help correct the impression!

I realize the man is underpaid, overworked and under-trained. Thanks to  the notorious 14f, he is probably from a remote small town, not used to the ways of a big city. He was almost certainly out of his depth and unequal to the demands of the strenuous job. I must also acknowledge he neither demanded a bribe nor was rude.

Yet I can't stop wondering how the system can run when the rules are unclear to those who have to follow and those expected to enforce them. How can you expect improvement through hardware (swanky camera) alone without the support structures (training, work conditions etc.)? What happened to the maxim that prevention is better than cure? When will we learn the virtues of urban planning and public transit?


  1. Jai,

    You should write articles about telangana agitation instead of just limiting yourself from commenting and debating. You have good writing skills, understanding of history and analytic power.

    What do you think?

  2. @విశ్వరూప్:

    Thanks a lot for your comment.

    I will definitely write about the Telangana movemenent too. The subject is an ocean and sometimes one does not know where to start. I just need to pick one facet of the demand, compose my thoughts & go..

    1. You can send your write up to existing telangana portals for getting wider reach.

  3. బుల్లబ్బాయ్April 24, 2012 at 4:18 PM

    Thanks to the notorious 14f, he is probably from a remote small town,

    interesting observation.

    you MUST write about telangana movement, as you have the knack of making such observations.

  4. @బుల్లబ్బాయ్: The 14f reference is incidental to the post.

    The primary focus here is "induction training" i.e. preparing an individual to perform efficiently on the job. This cop was not ready to begin with and inadequately trained on top of this.

    The other point is that results can only be achieved through an integrated srategy. Mere investment in "hardware" (or the more popular "infrastructure") will drain the coffers but yield zero or negative benefit.

  5. I am ambitious of raising voice on this kind of issues. Already planning to make videos of important junctions in the peak hours and to suggest simple solutions to the authorities, with the kind of observation and sincerity like yours. If you can, pls give me your email ID...

    1. Wishing you the best for your initiative. I am not sure how I can help but will try to do so where possible.

  6. Replies
    1. Thanks for the visit. Please post a "real" instead of "tests".

  7. Yes jai sir I to agree with u on lack of training both to the traffic cops n also to few peoples of roads.....n nowdays ve can find traffic cops hidden along the traffic junction with cameras clicking....n mailing tickets to home....recently I got one.....I no I never jump red light.....n my knowledge of traffic rules. is to processed, orange is to b caution n processed with caution. ....if u try to stop u dont know the vehicle behind vl stop r run our recent past I lost one of my close childhood buddy at my age just because he was so depress with loss of his 4yrs only daughter a year before in such a hit n run accident in broad daylight around 3pm by rtc bus at trimulgerry cross roads..later no police enquire nor any results nor camers working.....the wheels run over little child b4 her father n she was dead on the spot in fathers laps......n with span of year he to died......were sorrowful. I wonder when orange light gets on to stop r processed with caution. ...nfor the ticket I received of 200 bucks I decided vl not pay since I know I that I nevet jump red lights......but not sure weather cop had taken the clip when orange was on....hidding some were instead of performing his traffic duty by giving directions by standing on the roads........I vl fight till the end on this ticket. .....

    1. The loss is tragic. We spend so much on hardware & equipment but don't bother about processes. The investment on cameras is wasted when they don't work. Similarly educating people costs a fraction of the costs but is more effective in the long run.


Please be brief. Please respect everyone's privacy and do not reveal any private information about yourself or others.

Suggestions on improving the quality of this blog are always welcome. All other comments should be relevant to the subject of the post. I will delete all spam and messages with abusive or vulgar language.

All material in my blog is original. I will remove any copyrighted material if notified.

You may not use the material from my blog without my permission. I will not refuse any reasonable request as long as you credit me and provide a link to my own post.

If you post rejoinders, rebuttals or supplementary posts in your own blog, please leave a comment with a link.