October 07, 2013

Telangana river waters, irrigation & agriculture-8 (Indian water regime-an overview)

General

The previous chapter focused on the Indian trans-boundary legislation. We will now turn our attention to the overview, interpretation & criticism of the legislative regime. The present chapter will cover a broad overview of ISDA and the role of prior agreements in the legal landscape.

The language of the applicable legislation provides several pieces of interesting information.

The definition of "water disputes" in section 2 (c) of ISDA refers to three types of disputes. Trans-boundary water sharing is not explicitly included as a "water dispute": it is only covered through sections 2 (c) (i). More over, other types of disputes are specifically included. This leads to the inference that ISDA's primary role is the adjudication of water disputes including but not limited to water sharing. The very title of the act reinforces this inference.

ISDA title change through 2002 amendment may be interpreted to clarify the exclusion of lakes and ground water (excluding sub-surface streams) from the scope of the legislation. Lahiri notes "It became the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 only after the 2002 Amendment on and from August 6, 2002".

Section 3 of ISDA empowers state governments to raise water disputes. This (together with the title itself) can be inferred to bar individuals and other non-state players such informally defined "regions". Only a state government can pray for remedy if aggrieved.

Section 3 (and indeed ISDA itself) relates only to inter-state disputes. This is evident from both the language and the title. Taken together it is not possible for any one other than a state government (e.g. a regional council) to escalate a water dispute against another district, region or state. Distribution of water within a state (i.e. entry 17 rights) is clearly out of bounds.

I emphasize some of the above assertions are based on the sum total of my understanding after going through hundreds of pages of case law, tribunal reports & scholarly works. I realize I am not backing up some of these "on the spot" but this is to avoid increasing the pages of this work.

Commission, tribunal & courts

A commission appointed under section 130 of the 1935 act is limited to an advisory role. The Governor-General had wide discretionary power as confirmed in section 131 (9). He has the authority to take decisions or modify decisions he has already taken. The arbitrariness in his role as well as possible conflict with "his Majesty in Council" appear to be the main reasons why KWDT suspected "political considerations". The situation did not appear to have improved much from the pre-1935 period when the Griffin arbitration award was overturned by executive action.

Another distinction relates to the composition and appointment. Section 131 (1) of the 1935 act permits a commission to include individuals "having special knowledge and experience in irrigation, engineering, administration, finance or law", as decided by the Governor-General. The Indus Commission consisted of two members apart from the Chairman Justice BN Rau: both were engineers.

On the other hand, ISDA section 4 (2) limits the membership to serving (at the time of nomination) judges selected by the Chief Justice of India. Section 4 (3) relates to the appointment of assessors.

Unlike a commission setup under the 1935 act, a tribunal constituted under ISDA is empowered to pronounce a decision. This decision is binding on all the parties to the dispute as well as the central government. Tribunal decisions may not be questioned in a court of law. In practice this may not have worked out smoothly due to several reasons. Nevertheless a tribunal is a powerful adjudication institution.

Tribunals vs. courts

How do tribunals compare with courts? While a tribunal decision may not be challenged in any court, this relates only to the decision itself. This is not helpful in determining a tribunal's hierarchy insofar as stare decisis is concerned.

KWDT (volume IV, page 11) provides some clues:

"But a Tribunal constituted under a special statute has no common law or inherent power, see Kamaraja Nadar v. Kunju Thevar (1959) S.C.R. 583, 596 (Election Tribunal). However, if authorized by the statute by which it was constituted, it may review its decision, see Sree Meenakshi Mills Ltd. v. Their Workmen (1958) S.C.R. 878, 888 (Labor Appellate Tribunal under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947); Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure 13th Edition, page 1669; and may correct an accidental omission, see Tulsipur Sugar Company Ltd v. State of U.P. (1970) 1 S.C.R. 35, 37, 41-45 (Labor Court under U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947).

This Tribunal is set up under the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956. Its powers are circumscribed by the provisions of that Act. It has no inherent powers. It has some trappings of a Court. Section 9 of the Act gives the Tribunal some powers of a Civil Court and also enables it to regulate its practice and procedure. But the powers under section 151, 152 or under section 114 or Order 47 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure have not been conferred on it. Section 5(1) of the Act provides for reference of a water dispute and any matter appearing to be connected with or relevant to the water dispute to the Tribunal for adjudication. Section 5 (2) directs the Tribunal to investigate the matters referred to it and forward to the Central Government a report setting out the facts as found by it and giving its decision on the matters referred to it.

At pages 512 to 513 of Vol. II of the Report we have pointed out that a Tribunal appointed under the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 is not a permanent body and it cannot retain jurisdiction to modify its decision, apart from its statutory power to do so upon a reference made to it under section 5 (3) of the Act within three months of the decision".

The above may be considered in view of the following:

·         Tribunals frequently cite both case law (Indian & international) as well as other tribunal reports
·         The converse does not appear to be true. The Indian case law I referred frequently cited the appropriate tribunal but this was only for understanding the reason behind a decision
·         I have not come across a single instance where an Indian court cited a different tribunal's report

Not withstanding the jurisdictional bar, it is therefore safe to conclude a tribunal's report has little if any precedential value outside of water dispute adjudication. Even this may be limited by context e.g. CWDT's approach on basin transfers may not be relevant to different situations.

Prior agreements

KWDT (volume I, page 101) reading sections 2 (c) (ii) and 3 (c) of ISDA together determined: "if there is an agreement between the States relating to the use, distribution or control of the waters, that agreement should be implemented". GWDT (page 109) also cites this. KWDT also cites the Indus Commission's views "The agreement determines their respective rights and obligations and furnishes the agreed "law" on the subject".

On a similar note, Lahiri states the Indus Commission held "where there was an agreement, the agreement itself determine the limits and any transgression of this agreement would make the transgression actionable".

It may be noted that section 3 (c) refers to any agreement "relating to the use, distribution or control of such waters". While water sharing agreements are included, this may also include other agreements relating to the use/distribution/control of waters. There is also no restriction on the modalities of sharing. Agreements signed for Godavari water sharing adopted several methods including specific projects, sub-basins or part thereof, TMC shares as well as combinations of these.

In an agreement signed on July 12, 1974 Madhya Pradesh (MP), Gujarat, Maharashtra & Rajasthan agreed on several aspects relating to the dispute then being adjudicated by Narmada Water Disputes Tribunal (NWDT). Apart from agreeing the water quantity available at 75% dependability as 28 MAF (million acre-feet), the parties agreed to set aside 0.25 MAF & 0.50 MAF respectively for Maharashtra & Rajasthan. NWDT accordingly allocated this water to the two states in clause III of the decision.

GWDT also refused to interfere with valid agreements between states. The central government in its clarification 5 requested the tribunal to provide for a review as water available may become scarce with the passage of time. The tribunal refused the request stating "The decision of the Tribunal is based on the Agreements between the parties and there is no stipulation in the Agreements for the review of the decision. As such, we do not find it necessary to amend the Final Order in this respect".

Interpreting agreements

Andhra Pradesh v. Maharashtra & Ors, 2013 (Babhali barrage case) provides an interesting case study on how agreements are to be drafted. The case centered to a great extent around clause II (i) of the agreement dated October 6, 1975, between the two states. This agreement was included in the award as Annexure II vide clause V (A) (b). The relevant text is shown below for ready reference.

"II. (i) From the waters in the area of the Godavari basin below Paithan dam site on the Godavari and below Siddheswar dam site on the Purna and below Nizamsagar dam site on the Manjira and up to Pochampad dam site on the Godavari, Maharashtra can utilize waters not exceeding 60 TMC for new Projects including any additional use over and above the present sanctioned or cleared utilization, as the case may be".

AP argued inter alia the phrase "up to Pochampad dam site" includes the entire storage area of the dam. Maharashtra argued the phrase had to be interpreted literally i.e. "up to the concrete structure of the dam" as this meaning was used in other clauses of the agreement. Any other interpretation, it argued "would result into absurdity and make other clauses unworkable".

Maharashtra also contended that there was no limitation in its rights in its territory: "If the intention of Andhra Pradesh was that Maharashtra should not utilize the waters of Pochampad reservoir in its territory, such limitation would have been provided expressly".

Justice Rajendra Mal Lodha agreed with Maharashtra holding: "We are in agreement with Mr. TR Andhyarujina that if the intention of Andhra Pradesh was that Maharashtra should not utilize the waters of Pochampad reservoir in its territory, such limitation would have been provided expressly. When an agreement is entered into between two or more states, they have assistance of competent legal and technical minds available with them. The states do not have lack of drafting ability. Such agreement is drafted by trained minds. An agreement such as inter-state water sharing agreement would not leave its interpretation to chance. In our view, in the absence of any express limitation, except quantity, on the use of water by Maharashtra within its territory in Clause II i), the interpretation put by Andhra Pradesh to this Clause cannot be accepted".

Justice Lodha rejected AP's interpretation of the phrase "dam site" and upheld Maharashtra's contention. "The contention of Mr. K. Parasaran, learned senior counsel for Andhra Pradesh that up to Pochampad dam site in Clause II (i) and Clause II (ii) means up to the spread area of Pochampad dam and not the concrete structure of the dam does not appeal to us. The common meaning of the word “dam” is the structure across the stream, including the abutment on the sides".

The learned judge agreed with Maharashtra that an expression must carry the same meaning at all places where it is used, unless expressly provided otherwise. He wrote: "If the meaning of Pochampad dam site is given meaning as spread area of Pochampad dam, Clause V does not make sense and leads to absurdity. Clause V becomes workable only when Pochampad dam site is understood to mean concrete structure of the dam".

While agreeing with AP that "generally there cannot be lake/pondage of a project of one state within the lake/pondage of the project of another state", the court held this was not the focus of the case in the absence of engineering and hydrographic testimony. As the arguments on either side were centered on the interpretation of II (ii), this alone was considered for the judgment. The learned judge held "Like any other agreement, the terms of inter-state agreement ordinarily must be found out from the actual words employed therein".





"All agreements are contracts if they are made by the free consent of parties competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and with a lawful object, and are not hereby expressly declared to be void": section 10 (excerpt) of the Indian Contracts Act, 1872

September 22, 2013

Telangana river waters, irrigation & agriculture-7 (Trans-boundary water sharing)

Introduction to trans-boundary water sharing

Most of the discussion so far was about water rights of individuals and, by extension, other parties such as bodies corporate. We will now turn our attention to the examination of the rights of political entities such as states in a federal system and nations.

A trans-boundary river system is one that extends to more than one political entity. International law has often been applied (or considered for application) in inter-state water sharing. This work therefore clubs the two streams for the purpose of study while acknowledging the inherent differences.

Trans-boundary water sharing is a relatively new phenomenon. This body of knowledge & opinions emerged in response to water disputes.

International water sharing mechanisms emerged only in the second half of the twentieth century. This is not surprising as it sounds because the institutions such as United Nations did not exist earlier. Moreover the subject was not deemed important till disputes started emerging.

I will examine the situation in two phases. The Indian legal situation will be covered first while the international dimension (including the US) will be taken up later.

Inter-state water sharing in India

As we have seen earlier, the Indian position from 1935 has been that water rights is that water is a state subject while the regulation & development of inter-state rivers lies in the central domain. The relationship between the two is sometimes difficult to understand.

The legal foundation for inter-state water sharing in India rests on the following:

·         Entry 56 of List I
·         Entry 17 of List II
·         Government of India Act, 1935
·         Article 262
·         Inter-State (River) Waters Disputes Act, 1956 (ISDA)
·         Inter-State Water Disputes (Amendment) Act, 2002
·         River Boards Act, 1956 (RBA)

The two entries have been covered earlier. The others need to be looked in at some detail in the next few sections.

Government of India Act, 1935

The sections relevant to this study are 130-134 (pages 102-104) clubbed under "Interference with Water Supplies".

Section 130 labeled "Complaints as to interference with water supplies" is reproduced in full due to its importance:

"130. If it appears to the Government of any Governor's Province or to the Ruler of any Federated State that the interests of that Province or State, or any of the inhabitants thereof, in the water from any natural source of supply in any Governor's or Chief Commissioner's Province or Federated State, have been, or are likely to be, affected prejudicially by-

(a) any executive action or legislation taken or passed, or proposed to be taken or passed; or
(b) the failure of any authority to exercise any of their powers,

with respect to the use, distribution or control of water from that source, the Government or Ruler may complain to the Governor-General".

Section 131 relates to "Decision of complaints". Section 131 (1) requires the Governor-General to constitute a "Commission consisting of such persons having special knowledge and experience in irrigation, engineering, administration, finance or law, as he sees fit". The Governor-General can request the Commission to investigate "in accordance with such instructions as he may give to them" and submit a report. Although the section uses the word "shall", it also contains a proviso "unless he is of an opinion that the issues involved are not of sufficient importance to warrant such action".

Section 131 (2) requires a Commission so appointed to submit a report "setting out the facts as found by them and making such recommendations as they think proper". Section 131 (3) permits the Governor-General to refer the matter back to the Commission for further investigation and a further report, if he needs further explanation or guidance,

Section 131 (5) empowers the Governor-General, after considering the Commission's report, to "give such a decision and make such order, if any, in the matter of the complaint as he may deem proper". However, before the decision is made, if any Government or Ruler requests the Governor-General to refer the matter to "his Majesty in Council", he shall do so.

Section 131 (6) provides that an order issued by the Governor-General (or his Majesty in Council as the case may be) overrides any Act of the Provincial Legislature or state "to the extent of repugnancy".

Section 131 (7) empowers the Governor-General (or his Majesty in Council as the case may be) to vary any order or decision "if he considers it proper to do so" upon request by any Government or Ruler. Section 131 (9) reiterates the discretionary powers of the Governor-General in relation to section 131.

Section 132 relates to "Interference with water supplies of Chief Commissioner's Province" is similar to section 130. This section empowers the Governor-General to act on suo moto basis in the case of Chief Commissioner's Provinces "as if the Chief Commissioner's Province were similar to Governor's Province" and as if the Government had initiated the complaint.

Section 133 ("Jurisdiction of Courts excluded") bars the jurisdiction of any court including the federal court in matters relating to action taken under sections 130-132.

Section 134 labeled "Ruler of State may exclude application of provisions as to water supply". This section empowers rulers of federated states to exclude their states from the provisions of the foregoing section by declaring in the Instrument of Accession. This section never came into effect as the idea of federated states did not take off.

Article 262 of the Indian constitution

In view of its importance, the full text of the article is provided below:

"Adjudication of disputes relating to waters of inter State rivers or river valleys

(1) Parliament may by law provide for the adjudication of any dispute or complaint with respect to the use, distribution or control of the waters of, or in, any inter State river or river valley

(2) Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, Parliament may by law provide that neither the Supreme Court nor any other court shall exercise jurisdiction in respect of any such dispute or complaint as is referred to in clause (1) Coordination between States"

This article as well as the two lists are subject to wide ramifications. The import of these legal provisions are the subject of several judicial pronouncements and quasi-legal decisions.

Inter-State (River) Waters Disputes Act, 1956

The following captures the main elements of the act:

Section 2 defines important terms. Section 2 (c) defines "water disputes" as:

"(c) "water dispute" means any dispute or difference between two or more State Governments with respect to-

(i) the use, distribution or control of the waters of, or in, any inter-State river or river valley; or

(ii) the interpretation of the terms of any agreement relating to the use, distribution or control of such waters or the implementation of such agreement; or

(iii) the levy of any water rate in contravention of the prohibition contained in section 7".

Section 3 outlines the complaints covered by the act. In view of its importance, the full text of the section is provided below:

"3. Complaints by State Governments as to water disputes. Where it appears to the Government of any State that a water dispute with the Government of another State has arisen or is likely to arise by reason of the fact that the interests of the State, or of any of the inhabitants thereof, in the waters of an inter-State river or river valley have been, or are likely to be, affected prejudicially by-

(a) any executive action or legislation taken or passed, or proposed to be taken or passed, by the other State; or

(b) the failure of the other State or any authority therein to exercise any of their powers with respect to the use, distribution or control of such waters; or

(c) the failure of the other State to implement the terms of any agreement relating to the use, distribution or control of such waters, the State Government may, in such form and manner as may be prescribed, request the Central Government to refer the water dispute to a Tribunal for adjudication".

Section 4 relates to the constitution of a tribunal. The language of section 4 (1) is significant: "When any request under section 3 is received from any State Government in respect of any water dispute and the Central Government is of opinion that the water dispute cannot be settled by negotiations, the Central Government shall, by notification in the Official Gazette, constitute a Water Disputes Tribunal for the adjudication of the water dispute".

Section 5 outlines the modalities of the dispute adjudication. Section 5 (2) requires the tribunal to investigate the dispute and submit "a report setting out the facts as found by it and giving its decision on the matters referred to it". Section 5 (3) provides for a three month time for the affected states or the central government to raise clarifications or seek guidance. The tribunal may submit "a further report giving such explanation or guidance as it deems fit and in such a case, the decision of the Tribunal shall be deemed to be modified accordingly".

Section 6 relating to the implementation of the tribunal decision is reproduced in full due to its importance.

"6. Publication of decision of Tribunal. The Central Government shall publish the decision of the Tribunal in the Official Gazette and the decision shall be final and binding on the parties to the dispute and shall be given effect to by them".

A new section 6 (A) inserted by an amendment in 1980 empowers the central government to frame appropriate schemes necessary for the implementation of a tribunal decision. Section 6 (A) (1) is reproduced in full below due to its importance.

"6A. Power to make schemes to implement decision of Tribunal.

(1) Without prejudice to the provisions of section 6, the Central Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, frame a scheme or schemes whereby provision may be made for all matters necessary to give effect to the decision of a Tribunal".

The non obstante section 6 (A) (6) is reproduced in full below:

"(6) Every scheme framed under this section shall have effect notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force (other than this Act) or any instrument having effect by Virtue of any law other than this Act".

Section 8 excludes from the jurisdiction of tribunals "any dispute that may arise regarding any matter which may be referred to arbitration under the River Boards Act".

Section 9 outlines the powers of a tribunal. These confer a quasi-judicial status on the tribunal. These include, under section 9 (2) the right to ask the affected states to carry out or permit surveys or investigation considered necessary for the dispute adjudication.

Section 11 bars the jurisdiction of any court including the supreme court "in respect of any water dispute which may be referred to a Tribunal under this Act". As noted earlier, this is derived from article 262 (2).

Section 12 provides for dissolution of a tribunal "after it has forwarded its report and as soon as the Central Government is satisfied that no further reference to the Tribunal in the matter would be necessary".

The Inter-State Water Disputes (Amendment) Act, 2002

The original ISDA was amended significantly in 2002. The major changes are discussed below:

The title of the act was amended to Inter-State River Waters Disputes Act.

Section 4 (1) was amended to read:

"(1) When any request under section 3 is received from any State Government in respect of any water dispute and the Central Government is of opinion that the water dispute cannot be settled by negotiations, the Central Government shall, within a period not exceeding one year from the date of receipt of such request, by notification in the Official Gazette, constitute a Water Disputes Tribunal for the adjudication of the water dispute:

Provided that any dispute settled by a Tribunal before the commencement of the Inter-State Water Disputes (Amendment) Act, 2002 shall not be re-opened".

Sections 5 (2) was amended to read:

"(2) The Tribunal shall investigate the matters referred to it and forward to the Central Government a report setting out the facts as found by it and giving its decision on the matters referred to it within a period of three years

Provided that if the decision cannot be given for unavoidable reasons, within a period of three years, the Central Government may extend the period for a further period not exceeding two years".

Sections 5 (3) was amended to read:

"(3) If, upon consideration of the decision of the Tribunal, the Central Government or any State Government is of opinion that anything therein contained requires explanation or that guidance is needed upon any point not originally referred to the Tribunal, the Central Government or the State Government, as the case may be, within three months from the date of the decision, again refer the matter to the Tribunal for further consideration, and on such reference, the Tribunal may forward to the Central Government a further report within one year from the date of such reference giving such explanation or guidance as it deems fit and in such a case, the decision of the Tribunal shall be deemed to be modified accordingly

Provided that the period of one year within which the Tribunal may forward its report to the Central Government may be extended by the Central Government, for such further period as it considers necessary".

Section 6 was renumbered as 6 (1) and a new section 6 (2) was inserted "The decision of the Tribunal, after its publication in the Official Gazette by the Central Government under sub-section (1), shall have the same force as an order or decree of the Supreme Court".

Section 9 (1) (b) was amended permitting a tribunal to requisition "any data, as may be required by it". A new section 9 (A) inter alia requires the central government to maintain a national level database covering "water resources, land, agriculture, and matters relating thereto" for each river basin and empowers the verification of data supplied by the states.

Section 13 (2) (e) was amended to include service terms for assessors in the central government's purview.

River Boards Act, 1956

The key elements of the act are enunciated follows:

Section 2 asserts public interest: "it is expedient in the public interest that the Central Government should take under its control the regulation and development of inter-State rivers and river valleys to the extent hereinafter provided".

Section 4 covers the establishment of river boards. Section 4 (1) states "The Central Government may, on a request received in this behalf from a State Government or otherwise, by notification in the Official Gazette, establish a River Board for advising the Governments interested in relation to such matters concerning the regulation or development of an inter-State river or river valley or any specified part thereof and for performing such other functions as may be specified in the notification, and different Boards may be established for different inter State rivers or river valleys: Provided that no such notification shall be issued except after consultation with the Governments interested with respect to the proposal to establish the Board, the persons to be appointed as members thereof and the functions which the Board may be empowered to perform".

Section 13 relates to the jurisdiction of the boards setup under section 4. These include advice on several subjects including promotion and operation of irrigation/hydro-electric power/flood control/navigation schemes as well as conservation, control & optimum utilization of inter-state water resources.

Section 22 provides for arbitration of disputes between two or more governments arising out advice given by any river board as well as measures recommended by the board.





September 09, 2013

Stay calm in the face of provocations

Having failed to arouse ordinary Andhras in places like Vijayawada, anti-Telangana forces appear to be shifting gears. As the major driver behind the agitation is the refusal to let go of Hyderabad, they logically turn attention to the 400+ year old city.

September 7, 2013 is in many ways a red letter day for Telanganites, especially Hyderabadis. Andhra "NGO's" held a meeting in the historically significant Fateh Maidan grounds with the objective of obstructing Telangana formation.

During the long agitation for Telangana, the government created several hurdles to all attempts to hold meetings, rallies etc. Permission was denied even to national party meetings & cultural events. In most cases, the Telangana movement had to seek judicial intervention. The historic Telangana march was accorded conditional permission just before commencement. Preventive arrests, bindovers, road blocks & barbed wire have been the government's favored tools to greet Telangana citizens protesting for their rights. OU campus received "special treatment" at the hands of the khatmals.

In sharp contrast, the anti-Telangana meeting has received kid glove treatment right from the time the idea was floated to its "successful" completion. According to reports police provided escort to around 380 private buses hired by the agitators. The railways added additional cars to trains reaching Hyderabad to accommodate others. Wonderful to see the government turning over a new leaf and respecting the fundamental rights of Indian citizens!

Wait a minute, this friendly reception is limited only to those opposing Telangana. MRPS has been denied permission to hold a meeting on September 6, 2013. OU students were refused the right to hold a meeting in the historic Nizam college. TJAC request to hold a peace rally was negated.

The ground cited for the denial is the possibility of tempers flaring up leading to violence. A good argument but how can MRPS meeting the previous day lead to clashes? How is Manda Krishna Madiga's demand to exempt schools, social welfare hostels & buses from strikes less democratic a right than that of those opposing Telangana formation?

If the proximity of the two venues could lead to trouble, a prudent alternative would be to ask either party (or both) to shift to a different location. The government under an avowedly anti-Telangana chief minister has chosen not to do so.

What about the possibility of violence breaking out at the meeting itself? The police imposed 19 conditions to the permission. These include limiting the attendance to government employees. No assurance was obtained from the organizers on any of these.

What were the intentions of the meeting organizers? Some clues can be found below:

This meeting is being called an NGO meeting by the media. This is a misleading term. The meeting was actually conducted under the aegis of a group styled as Samaikhya (sic!) Rashtra Parirakshana Vedika (SRPV).

SRPV constituted a committee to coordinate the Hyderabad meeting. Only two of the 28 committee members are NGOs. Three are from RTC while another six are teachers or other government employees. The committee is dominated by non-employees.

True Mr. Paruchuri Ashok Babu, the unelected Andhra NGO "leader" is the chairman of the committee. This by itself does not substantiate the claim that the meeting was for employees, much less NGOs.

Ashok Babu was interviewed on Gemini News on August 19, 2013. He explained two problems for Andhra employees due to bifurcation.

·         He (yes, he specifically said "I") has been selected to Secretariat at Hyderabad. He therefore believes he is entitled to this location & department throughout his career.
·         If the state is bifurcated, whole of residual AP will become one zone. Srikakulam employees can be transferred to Chittoor & vice-versa.

Towards the end of his interview, he admitted the solution might be in a compromise. He frankly said he was jostling to get a better deal and hoped the compromise will be towards "unity" and not bifurcation.

During the run-up to the present meeting, neither of these issues were raised. Rather the avowed purpose changed to "save Andhra Pradesh".

SRPV called for registration from netizens wishing to attend the meeting. The registration form lists only for name, email ID & mobile phone. No employment details like department, location were sought.

If the organizers were not planning to mobilize non-employees, why did they ask all & sundry to register?

Dileep Konatham called up the Andhra NGO office to enquire how he can obtain an ID card to attend the meeting. He was told an ordinary ID card like a ration card is enough. When he specifically mentioned he was not a government employee, they said "మరేం పర్లేదండి. ప్రభుత్వ ఉద్యోగస్తులే కాదు, ఎవరైనా రావచ్చండి. మీదగ్గర రేషన్ కార్డు లాంటి గుర్తింపు పత్రం ఉంటే చాలు మీరు వచ్చేయవచ్చు. పోలీసులు ఏమీ అనరండి. అక్కడ మనాళ్లుంటారు, వాళ్లు మిమ్మల్ని రిసీవ్ చేసుకుంటారు”

Andhra NGO's reportedly issued receipts to those without ID cards. How can a government employee register attendance if he does not have one?

B. Raghavulu of CPM and Majlis's Akbaruddin Owaisi (yes, he of the inflammatory speech fame) were invited to the meeting. The fact that these politicians declined does not detract from the fact the NGOs did not intend to stick to the condition of limiting to employees.

One Mr. Ramarao speaking on NTV pooh pooh'd MRPS's attack threats. While this is commendable, he went on to provocative MRPS by claiming it owes its existence to Andhra government employee support. He called Manda Krishna a "kirayi goonda" forcing the anchor to step in and stop.

Speaking to the press on September 6, Ashok Babu said his organization would not take responsibility for any unwarranted events. He also said they would not be able to conclude the meeting by 5 PM as permitted. He specifically repudiated the conditions placed on the meeting by the police.

The intentions of the organizers appear to two fold: provocation and an assertion that "Hyderabad belongs to all Telugus". They were willing to go to any extent to establish these. The state government and the police did their best to support these intentions.

It has been reported that there was virtually no checking at the meeting. Families were also allowed. Visuals of a young girl standing on the stage were telecast prominently.

Congress politician & singer "Ghazal" Srinivas was personally escorted to the stage by PSR Anjaneyulu, a police officer censured by the courts several times. Srinivas returned the favor by mauling the national anthem. Former Advocate General Mohan Reddy, another non-employee gracing the stage, stood as a mute spectator to this hideous insult.

Dr. Mitra, a former PRP ideologue, was another politician honored at the stage. An elderly woman called Satyavani believed to be a Loksatta activist delivered a pithy speech comparing Telangana to the defeated Kouravas.

Ramakrishna Reddy, an RTC union leader under criminal investigation, was the only government employee to be given a prominent place. All the others hailed from other sections such as journalism, law & student bodies.

The organizers did not honor the other conditions like time of meeting and the permitted attendance. The estimated crowd of around 30,000 was double the permitted 15,000.

An unarmed youth Balraj Yadav was beat up by the agitating Andhras for the "crime" of waving a black flag. The perpetrator is believed to be a "leader" of the YSR party.

The agitators raised slogans & took out a rally in a clear violation of the conditions. Some agitators made gestures threatening to behead Telangana students. The "NGO" responsible is considered to be a TDP activist from Uravakonda.

The khatmals as usual excelled themselves. Police entered the Nizam college hostel and attacked students eating breakfast. They forcibly evicted Kranti Kiran, a lone unarmed journalist covering the beat. Even Srinivas Goud, a fellow constable, was attacked when he raised Jai Telangana slogan.

Andhra politicians who stayed behind the scenes claim the meeting was a grand success. No doubt whoever paid for the shenanigan got more than his money's worth. They not only got to hold a meeting in Hyderabad but received a red carpet treatment from a benign circar. As a bonus, they got to thrash a few lazy drunkard feudal Naxalite jihadi separatist Telaban alaga janam J

More seriously, did the organizers achieve their objectives? By restricting the attendance, speakers & even the media to Andhras they themselves conceded their demand is limited to 13 districts. Despite trying hard, they failed to invite retaliation.

The euphoria over the meeting will not last long. The sight of a young man raising a banner of revolt amidst thousands of hostile individuals will stay etched in memory. Ms. Satyvani, this is Abhimanyu facing the Kouravas in Chakravyuh!

What should we do? Many Telanganites argue we should stay calm because retaliation will only strengthen the propaganda & fear psychosis built assiduously over the years.

I reject this argument. The propaganda machinery does not need a real incident. They will anyway rake up some stray happening trying to stoke fears.

We should stay calm in the face of provocations because of our own values, not out of fear of adverse propaganda. We should remain peaceful because tolerance is the heart of our tahzeeb. In this city named after Imam Ali, the spirit of qurbani will prevail over all forms of antagonism.


Stay calm in the face of provocations and celebrate the advent of the festival season with joy, peace and an indomitable spirit.