September 03, 2013

Telangana river waters, irrigation & agriculture-6 (Evolution of Indian water law)

Water in the ancient Indian culture

Water plays a crucial role in the ancient Indian way of life that is recognized both in the Vedas and the Upanishads. Water is treated as the second of the five primordial elements (panchamahabhuth).

Varuna is the god of water, sky and oceans. Befittingly, Makara (crocodile) is his mount. Rather surprisingly, rain & thunder are the domain of another dikpalaka (guardian of direction) i.e. Indra, the leader of gods.

Lakshmi, the consort of Vishnu, is the daughter of the ocean. Ganga (Ganges), the celestial river, is one of the consorts of Mahadeva.

Matsya (fish), the first avatar of Vishnu, appeared to Satyavrata (later known as Manu, the law giver) when he was washing his hands in a river. The story detailed in Matsyapurana speaks about a deluge and a huge boat that Manu housed with his family, animals & seeds in order to repopulate the earth (somewhat like Noah's ark).

Kurma (tortoise), the second avatar, contributed to the churning of the celestial ocean that culminated in the discovery of nectar.

The Indian epics too contain several references to water. Sage Bhagiratha is credited with the descent of the Ganga to earth. Ganga is also linked to the story of Santanu & Bhishma.

Vasudeva while spiriting away his newborn son Krishna from the evil Kamsa crosses a flooded Jamuna. In a different story, Krishna challenges the need to pray to Indra for rain. The story ends with Krishna lifting a hill on his little finger to provide a shield for his people from the rain unleashed by Indra in retaliation.

Water is an essential component of all Hindu rituals. Most pujas require the use of water from a kalasa (pot). Ritual purification and bathing are quite common.

Water is essential in death as well. After cremation, the family members take a ritual bath in the river. The ashes from the pyre are ceremonially cast in a river in a separate ceremony. Sinners cross the Vaitarna river on their way to naraka (hell).

Rivers like Ganga, Jamuna, Krishna, and Cauvery are treated as sacred. Their names are often suffixed with the local language word for "mother". River banks are dotted with temples throughout India. A sangam (confluence of rivers) is likewise treated as a sacred place. Triveni sangam at Prayag (the confluence of Ganga, Jamuna and the mythical river Saraswati), a major Kumbh Mela venue, is considered to be one of the holiest spots in the world. Several major rivers celebrate similar pushkar festivities.

Indian law under Hindu rulers

MS Vani published a paper titled "Customary Law and Modern Governance of Natural Resources in India- Conflicts, Prospects for Accord and Strategies". This paper is in part based on a Ford Foundation project called “Law and Custom in Water Resources Administration in Uttaranchal State, India”.

Vani describes (pages 7-13) in great detail the Hindu jurisprudence framework. She writes the framework was based on three "delicately balanced" sources: dharma, royal order and custom. She cites AL Basham that dharma and custom were generally held inviolable. Kings were expected to uphold dharma and let subjects follow their customs.

Vani cites Basham on the relationship between the three sources: "Generally, Dharma was thought to override all other sources of law, though the Arthashastra maintained that the royal ordinance overrides the others. However, this doctrine is ascribed to the totalitarianism of the Mauryas, which few jurists would have supported".

Vani lists the four bases of justice (in the order of increasing importance) citing Arthashastra verses 3.1.39 & 40: dharma based on truth; evidence based on witness testimony; custom based on accepted tradition and royal edicts based on promulgated law.

Cullet & Gupta (page 4) cite the same four bases from Arthashastra. They concur with Vani that the kings were required to ensure dharma and let existing customs continue.

Water rights under Hindu law have been described earlier in adequate detail. The brief discussion here is to establish the theoretical foundation of these rights.

Indian Water law under Muslim rulers

Cullet & Gupta cite (page 5) IA Siddiqui to show the "Islamic rulers refrained from significant intervention in existing arrangements". This may have been with because "the relatively high availability of water in India precluded conflicts with Islamic norms".

Vani concurs (page 13) quoting Marc Galanter:

"Under Muslim rule, the judicial system remained a plural one. Muslim populations were governed by Muslim law in criminal, civil and family matters and disputes settled before royal courts established in cities and administrative centers. Hindus were generally allowed their own tribunals in civil matters. When such matters came before royal courts, Hindu law was applied and sustained by the sanctions of the State. While there was a hierarchy of courts and rights of appeal, there was no supervision of lower courts. No attempt was made to control the administration of law in the villages".

These findings are consistent with the fact that India was generally not regarded as a dar al-salam under Muslim rule.

Water law under the British Raj

Cullet & Gupta write (pages 5-6) the British did not, until 1857 (i.e. under "company rule") interfere with local custom unless it impacts their own policies. After the assumption of direct crown control in 1858, they began to invest in and regulate canals & irrigation.

The authors cite Dellapenna:

"British colonial water law had two main strands. First, control over water and rights to water were regulated through the progressive introduction of common law principles, emphasizing the rights of landowners to access water. For surface waters, riparian rights allow a landowner the right to take a reasonable portion of the flow of a watercourse".

The laws established in the above pursuit include:

·         Embankment Regulation, 1829
·         Bengal Embankment Act, 1855
·         Northern India Canal and Drainage Act, 1873
·         Indian Easements Act, 1882

Cullet & Gupta consider the Northern India Canal and Drainage Act, 1873, as an important enactment in the evolution of Indian water law. This law regulated irrigation, navigation and drainage in much of North India.

They write "While this Act did not directly assert the state’s ownership over surface waters, it recognized the right of the Government to ‘use and control for public purposes the water of all rivers and streams flowing in natural channels, and of all lakes’".

This trend was strengthened over time with the passage of other laws. The colonial rulers also introduced the division of responsibilities and a conflict resolution mechanism. According to Cullet & Gupta:

"The Government of India Act (1935) empowered the provinces to take decisions on water supply, irrigation, canals, drainage and embankments, water storage and hydropower. Conflicts between provinces and/or princely states were subjected to the jurisdiction of the Governor General who could appoint a commission to investigate the sufficiently important conflicts".

Lahiri looks at water rights in the early colonial period and explains the situation in greater detail:

"More provincial autonomy came in the form of Entry 19 of List-2 to the 7th Schedule of the Government of India Act, 1935 by which power to legislate on “water, that is to say water supplies, irrigation and canal, drainage and embankments, water storage and water power” was transferred by Entry 19 of List 2 in the 7th Schedule of the Act of 1935 to the Provincial Government. The executive authority of the provinces were also made co-extensive or co-terminus with its legislative power by virtue of Section 49 (2) of the Act of 1935 and subject to the restrictions placed by Sections 130 to 133 of the Act of 1935.

The Provincial Government was free to do what it thought fit in respect of water supplies within its province. However, this was subject to the provisions of Sections 130 to 133 under which the Governor General could, on the basis of a complaint by one province against another regarding interference with its water supplies, appoint a Commission to investigate the matter and submit a report on the basis of which the Governor General could pass final orders unless any party to the dispute desired a reference to His Majesty in Council for final order. Such orders made by the Governor General or His Majesty in Council, as the case may be, were binding on the provinces affected thereby unless varied. All these central safeguards indicate that even under the Government of India Acts, 1919 and 1935 no province could take action which would prejudicially affect the interest of another province or its people".

KWDT reiterates (volume I, page 9) the position: "Under the Government of India Act, 1935, water became an exclusive provincial subject and specific provision was made for settlement of water disputes".

KWDT returns to the subject later (volume I, page 104) elaborating in greater detail:

"Under the Government of India Act, 1935, as from the 1st April, 1937, water became an exclusive provincial subject and specific provision was made in sections 130 to 134 of the Act for decision of water disputes".

Godavari Water Disputes Tribunal (GWDT) agrees with this assessment stating (page 95): "British India was subject to the unitary control of the Government of India and even the princely states were under its paramount control. Under the Government of India Act, 1935 water became an exclusive provincial subject and specific provision was made for the settlement of water disputes".

The situation prior to the passing of the 1935 act (labeled "pre-genesis" by Lahiri) was to a good extent different. CWDT (volume IV, page 36) mentions the dispute between Madras & Mysore on the former's insistence on a particular flow of water in its territories ahead of the 1924 agreement on Cauvery water sharing. The award of the arbitrator, Justice HR Griffin, was challenged by Madras. CWDT summarizes the final decision: "In due course it went upto the Secretary of States who set aside the said award with certain directions".

The situation before the 1935 Act is summarized by KWDT (volume I, page 104) as:

"Till 1921, irrigation works were subject to the unitary control of the Central P.W.D. Since 1921, under the Government of India Act, 1915, as amended by the Government of India Act, 1919, "Water supplies" became a provincial subject, but even then the Government of India could decide inter-Provincial water disputes".

"The Government of India used to decide inter-Provincial water disputes on administrative considerations".

"Under the Government of India Act, 1935, as from the 1st April, 1937, water became an exclusive provincial subject and specific provision was made in sections 130 to 134 of the Act for decision of water disputes".

KWDT is somewhat skeptical about the pre-independence situation (volume I, page 104): "Though the Government of India in the exercise of its powers of paramount control professed to apply rules of international law and the precept of the greatest good to the greatest number irrespective of political boundaries, the actual settlement of the disputes used to be made on political considerations".

Vani analyzes (pages 19-20) the impact of the introduction of the colonial legal system in Indian traditions. She states this made the system rigid, reduced the importance of the traditional dispute resolution mechanisms and in general paved the way for disintegration of customs preserved for ages. She writes: "The rule of stare decisis put paid to the flexibility of Indian law by obviating innovation in shastric and customary law to meet changes in community opinion and sentiment. The modern legal machinery ‘forces local law to fall in line with national standards’".

Water law in independent India

Lahiri explains the legal situation in India is similar to that of England. He quotes Halsbury's Laws of England:

“86. Rights in flowing water at common law. Although certain rights as regards flowing water are incident to the ownership of riparian property, the water itself, whether flowing in a known and defined channel or percolating through the soil, is not at common law, the subject of property or capable of being granted to anybody. Flowing water is only publici juris in the sense that it is public or common to all who have a right of access to it.

87. Statutory rights in flowing water. Proprietary interests in water flowing in certain channels may be, and have in certain instances been, created by Act of Parliament. Rights can also be obtained to abstract water”.

KWDT (volume I; page 79) reiterates the Indian legal situation vis-à-vis that of England:

"The Indian law is based on the common law of England. The common law doctrine has been considerably modified in England by the Water Resources Act 1963, Chapter 38, sections 23 to 32, but the general Indian law continues to be the same as before".

The term "publici juris" needs to be understood carefully. It is understood to mean "public right" or "common property" available to everyone in the community. This does not make it a property in the conventional sense. Flowing water, like air or light, is not susceptible to ownership by anyone including the state.

Lahiri shows the Government of India Act, 1935 continued to be applicable even after independence till the Indian constitution came into effect. He also demonstrates the Indian constitution broadly adopts the scheme of Government of India Act, 1935. For instance, state control over water enshrined under entry 19 of list-2 of the 7th schedule of the 1935 act were reiterated under entry 17 of list 2 to the 7th schedule of the constitution. The central government role was defined under entry 56 in list 1 on lines similar to the 1935 act. Similarly the exclusion of jurisdiction clause from section 133 of the 1935 act was embodied in article 262 (2).

The applicable text from the lists is shown below:

Entry 56 of List I ("union list") of Seventh Schedule: "Regulation and development of inter-State rivers and river valleys to the extent to which such regulation and development under the control of the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be expedient in the public interest".

Entry 17 under List II ("state list") of Seventh Schedule: "Water, that is to say, water supplies, irrigation and canals, drainage and embankments, water storage and water power subject to the provisions of Entry 56 of List I".

The year 1956 can be regarded as a milestone in the history of the Indian water law. Inter-State (River) Waters Disputes Act (ISDA) came into effect paving the way for the resolution of simmering inter-state water disputes. The lesser known but potentially significant River Boards Act (RBA) that enables the setting up of a board to regulate and develop inter-state rivers and river valleys was also adopted in the same year.

With the introduction of a sovereign constitution derived from "we the people", the Indian jurisprudence firmly asserts the supremacy of constitutional law over other sources. In a way, Kautilya's dictum on the inter-relationship between the "four bases of justice" has now been established albeit under a democratic regime.

Water law in India: a brief summary

The evolution of water law in India can be broadly divided into the following "eras":

·         Before the assumption of direct crown control in 1858
·         1858-1935 till the passing of the 1935 act
·         Till 1950, when the Indian constitution came into effect
·         After 1950

It can be argued that the dates are slightly different e.g. perhaps the current phase began in 1956. What is more important, however, is to note these different periods correspond to qualitative changes in the legal perspective surrounding water rights. It is unquestionable that the four eras are demonstrably different.

Lahiri terms the period 1949-2004 as the evolution phase. He traces the history of the ISDA act from the original draft in 1955 till its adoption in 1956.

It is interesting to note these eras do not necessarily relate to or arise from regime change. For instance, the "traditional rights era" continued through Hindu kingdoms, Muslim rule and company hegemony.




"Hinduism is like the Ganga, pure and unsullied at its source but taking in its course the impurities in the way. Even like the Ganga it is beneficent in its total effect. It takes a provincial form in every province, but the inner substance is retained everywhere": MK Gandhi

September 01, 2013

Reporting from Vijayawada

My blog post titled Telangana march- a first hand account was well received both by friends and netizens in general. This is my most popular post till date both on hits and comments.

A private visit to Vijayawada provides me an opportunity to provide a similar eye witness from the "other side".

Two of my colleagues and I just returned after spent a day in Vijayawada to attend a function. We arrived by an overnight train and checked into a hotel near the railway station. The function was just off Bandar Road, approximately half way between Benz Circle (the most important intersection in the city) and Kankipadu (the Eastern boundary). The drive in both directions gave sufficient opportunity to study the impact of the ongoing anti-Telangana "movement" (aka Operation Grab Hyderabad).

By an interesting coincidence, our visit date (August 30, 2013) was exactly one month after the Congress resolution in favor of Telangana. The "fast unto death" undertaken at the Chanchalguda jail by its most famous under-trial inmate, the Cuddappah MP YS Jaganmohan Reddy (Jagan), had been forcibly interrupted by the police the previous night.

A short while after landing, I overheard a conversation between two locals. It ran on the following lines:

·         Individual 1 (a Jagan fan): what is happening about Telangana formation?
·         Individual 2 (did not sport any outward political links): Have you ever been to Hyderabad?
·         Individual 1: no
·         Individual 2: why do you care then?
·         Individual 1: Telangana people are getting their state. What are we getting?
·         Individual 2: what do you want?
·         Individual 1 (changing track): it would have never happened if YS (the late YS Rajashekhar Reddy) had been alive
·         Individual 2: గాడిద గుడ్డేం కాదూ ("gadidaguddem kadoo" roughly equal to "nonsense")
We chartered an autorickshaw to go to our function. The autowala was an interesting soul who spoke most of the way (much like a New York or Bombay cabbie). When he lamented the ongoing bus strike, I suggested he should be pleased because it improves his earnings. He politely disagreed pointing out that the auto business depended mostly on people who reached the city by bus from nearby districts.

Before we hit Bandar Road, we encountered a small shamiana housing a relay fast by a group calling itself "Samaikyandhra Doctors JAC'. The shamiana size was just over a typical Hyderabadi pan shop. The modest size was adequate for the handful of individuals sitting there.

Before we reached Benz Circle, we saw three more shamianas. Two of these were manned by Government employees and had about 20 odd middle aged men. The third shamiana housing "friends of Vangaveeti Radha" relay strikes in support of Jagan's fast had just three people, the only youth we encountered in the "movement".

A small group of around 30 people were staging a rasta roko just after Benz circle. I thought this was a strategic location being right opposite the Enadu office (if you save time for the press they will reciprocate in kind by providing good coverage). We had to make a slight detour that added around 5 minutes to our journey time.

There were two more shamianas after Benz Circle. The one outside Siddartha Engineering College had around 15 male staff members but no students. Another one near the Tatigadapa Circle was smaller with perhaps 10 people.

The public spirit of the shamianawalas (or perhaps their modest expectations) was clear from the fact that none of these encroached on the road. All were well within the sidewalk & shoulder.

There was no shamiana outside the Telugu Desham Party (TDP) office.

I counted 6-7 large size banners on the way. A couple of these belonged to the TDP while the rest were put up by the Congress. TDP also put up a couple of banners welcoming their party supremo Chandrababu Naidu without mentioning the present agitation. TDP office had a few large anti-Telangana posters but these were all inside the compound and therefore not prominently visible to passers by.

The road dividers along the entire stretch were decorated with small posters spaced at around 100 feet. Just under half of these were put up by one Devineni Avinash, son of Congress politician Devineni Rajashekhar alias Nehru. The others were all non political with birthday wishes to movie actor turned politician Chiranjeevi hogging the limelight. Birthday wishes to actor Mahesh Babu and commercial posters contributed the rest.

Avinash's posters had the photograph of the late Potti Sreeramulu apart from himself. Looks like he does not agree with his party leader Tulasi Reddy's contention that Sreeramulu was never linked to the formation of Andhra Pradesh. Given his family's naming/nick naming conventions, I was surprised to see Nehru giving up the tradition of naming their progeny after national leaders. Or perhaps there was indeed a great freedom fighter called Avinash about whom I am ignorant.

On the way back, the situation changed to some extent. The rasta roko opposite Enadu ended. The Tatigadapa crowd disappeared totally while the three Jagan (or Radha) fans had left for the day. The shamiana's beauty was enhanced greatly by a solitary homeless individual taking shelter from the sun. Three other shamianas had shrunk to a half of its previous strength.

One shamiana housing a relay strike by Government employees had grown quite a bit. There were around 50 people who continued to exhibit the same public spirit of not obstructing traffic. My initial surprise vanished as we came closer: Lagadapati Rajagopal, the Andhra businessman-cum-politician was addressing the group. I could not catch what he spoke as we breezed past at a high speed.

The action was almost entirely run by men past their youth. There were no women and very few young folks.

Someone I met at the function said a trade bandh was on. I was thankful for this information as there was no way I could have figured this out on my own. Just a handful of stores near Benz Circle were closed or operating under half shutters.

Unfortunately for us, we missed a couple of important events. Two senior railway trade union leaders retired on this day. Their respective parties tool out rallies in felicitation. According to a reliable eye witness, the smaller of the two attracted over 300 people. The banners announcing these events were more numerous and larger than that of the anti-Telangana folks.

Thirty days after the Congress's Telangana resolution, the biggest political news in the political capital of Andhra, is that two senior leaders of rival railway trade unions retired on the same day.


Wishing you a peaceful, joyous & healthy retired life, gentlemen!

August 26, 2013

Central institutions in Hyderabad & the "presidential order"

I am interrupting my blog series on river waters, irrigation & agriculture to investigate the link between the presidential order and central institutions in Hyderabad.

Background

Satya, a prominent commenter at Nalamotu Chakravarthy's blog, and I had exchanged a few points about the development of Hyderabad. One of these relates to the role the presidential order had on the development of Hyderabad.

The relevant excerpts are produced below:

satya says:
August 24, 2013 at 7:38 am

Hyderabad getting attention is not only  based on logical model, it is even attested by Presidential order

Jai Gottimukkala says:
August 24, 2013 at 8:12 am

I will be surprised if presidential order reference to Hyderabad can be demonstrated

satya says:
August 24, 2013 at 3:51 pm

Presidential Order
Programme in the State Plan to develop  the infrastructure of the State will benefit the capital city. Other schemes intended specifically for urban development, housing, water supply, expansion of educational and medical facilities etc., also from part of the State Plan. The formula contemplates that special assistance from the Centre to supplement these programmes would also be available. As the formula emphasised the importance of the planned development of the capital city,  Government may also consider the constitution of a suitable Capital Development Authority.”
As per the guidelines of PO, HUDA is formed on 2nd oct 1975”

(Emphasis original: Jai)

General

The sequence of events leading to the anti-Mulki (aka Jai Andhra agitation) is briefly outlined below:

·         The supreme court case Director Of Industries v. V. Venkata Reddy & Ors was decided on October 3, 1972. Chief Justice Sarv Mittra Sikri delivered a unanimous decision on behalf of the six member full bench of the apex court.
·         The honorable court held Mulki rules continued to be valid not withstanding the striking down of section 3 of Public Employment (Requirement as to Residence) Act, 1957 (Act 44 of 1957).
·         Interpreting the legislative intent behind the 1957 Act, the learned judge held if section 3 was struck down, so would section 2. Justice Sikri wrote: "In, our view it is clear that Parliament would not have enacted S. 2 without s.3 as far as Telangana is concerned".
·         The net effect was the reinstatement of the Mulki rules with retrospective effect
·         As Telangana was ruled to be out of the ambit of the 1957 Act, the judgment also effectively abolished the fifteen year time limit set in the Act.

This judgment provoked a widespread agitation in the Andhra & Rayalaseema districts. The political leadership of the two regions, with a few rare exceptions, threw their hats in the ring and led the agitation from the front. While a full discussion of the agitation is unwarranted at this time, it is sufficient to acknowledge the violence unleashed by the agitation wreaked great havoc.

The central government imposed president's rule on January 10, 1973. Indira Gandhi initiated measures to restore law and order and simultaneously tried to broker a solution to the vexed problem. The president's rule was lifted on December 10, 1973 after eleven months of strife.

The "solution" as worked out took the following route:

·         A so called six point formula (SPF) enunciated by Congressmen across the regions through a statement on September 21, 1973
·         Clarifications issued by Congressmen across the regions through a statement on October 22, 1973
·         Passing of the Constitution (Thirty-Second Amendment) Act, 1973
·         Insertion of new articles 371 D and 371 E as enabled by the thirty second amendment
·         Issuance of the Andhra Pradesh Public Employment, (Organization of Local Cadres and Regulation of Direct Recruitment) Order, 1975 (aka G.S.R. 524 (E)) on October 18, 1975 as enabled by article 371 D.
·         Establishment of Hyderabad Central University (HCU) as enabled by article 371 E

SPF

The statement of September 21, 1973 outlines the six principles (points) agreed upon:

·         Point 1 stresses accelerated development of the backward areas and planned development of the capital with specific resources earmarked for these purposes. The point inter alia calls for association of backward area representatives and suitable experts in formulating & monitoring backward area development. The point does not mention any such mechanism for the development of the capital.
·         Point 2 relates to the establishment of HCU and preference to local candidates in educational institutions
·         Point 3 relates to preference to local candidates in direct recruitment of state government employees other than specifically stated exemptions
·         Point 4 calls for the constitution of a high power administrative tribunal to deal with the grievances of services regarding appointments, seniority, promotion and other allied matters
·         Point 5 calls for a constitution amendment to ensure the above principles can be implemented without giving rise to unnecessary litigation
·         Point 6 is quoted in full: "The above approach would render the continuance of Mulki Rules and Regional Committee unnecessary"

The statement concludes with the remark: "We are convinced that the accelerated development of the backward areas and planned development of the State capital are the major factors which will help in successfully implementing the above principles, We would, therefore, urge upon the Central Government to take a generous view in the matter of financial assistance to the State for the development of these areas".

SPF clarifications

The statement of October 22, 1973 provides further clarifications on the six point formula. This statement has eleven paragraphs:

·         Paragraph 1 highlights the basic approach of SPF: "The formula was intended to indicate the basic approach to promote the accelerated development of backward areas, a balanced development of the State as a whole and to provide equitable opportunities to different areas of State in the matter of education, employment and career prospects in public services, with a view achieve a fuller emotional integration of the people of Andhra Pradesh".
·         Paragraph 2 emphasizes the accelerated development of backward areas. The statement leaves the task of identifying the backward areas to the popular government
·         Paragraphs 3, 4 & 6 delves into the modalities of the development of backward areas
·         Paragraph 5 is quoted in full: "Programme in the State Plan to develop the infrastructure of the State will benefit the capital city. Other schemes intended specifically for urban development, housing, water supply, expansion of educational and medical facilities etc., also from part of the State Plan. The formula contemplates that special assistance from the Centre to supplement these programmes would also be available. As the formula emphasised the importance of the planned development of the capital city, Government may also consider the constitution of a suitable Capital Development Authority".
·         Paragraphs 7 through 10 delve at some length into the definition of local candidate, preference mechanisms and related mechanisms.
·         Paragraph 11 reiterated: "We are satisfied that the six-point formula provide all the necessary policy directives for comprehensive detailed schemes to be drawn up and implemented in due course. The association of the Central Government in the implementation of the six-point formula will make available to the State Government the necessary expertise and national guidance. As soon as a popular Government is restored in Andhra Pradesh the stage would be set for the State and the Centre to take upon themselves without any delay the implementation of the formula".

Thirty Second Amendment

The statement of objects & reasons traces the history leading to the SPF evolution. It inter alia reads: "This  Bill  has  been brought forward to  provide  the  necessary constitutional authority for giving effect to the Six-Point Formula in so  far as it relates to the provision of equitable opportunities  for people  of different areas of the State in the matter of admission  to educational  institutions and public employment and constitution of an Administrative  Tribunal  with  jurisdiction  to  deal  with    certain disputes  and  grievances relating to public services.  The Bill  also seeks  to  empower Parliament to legislate for establishing a  Central University  in the State and contains provisions of an incidental  and consequential  nature  including the provision for the  validation  of certain  appointments  made  in the past.  As  the   Six-Point  Formula provides  for the discontinuance of the Regional Committee constituted under  clause  (1) of article 371 of the Constitution, the  Bill  also provides for the repeal of that clause".

It is pertinent to note development of the capital is not mentioned anywhere in the statement of objects & reasons. The fact that this matter is not covered in the amendment therefore comes as no surprise.

Presidential order

The order has 7 sections.

·         Sections 1 & 2 relate to title, commencement & definitions
·         Section 3 requires the state government to organize local cadres
·         Sections 4 & 5 relates to the allocation of individual employees to the local cadres and the associated transfers
·         Section 6 delves into local areas
·         Section 7 goes into a good amount of detail on local candidates

The presidential order is authorized by article 371 D that in turn was inserted by the thirty second amendment. The order therefore is as silent about the capital development as the amendment, its source of authority.

Initial reaction

The following conclusions may be drawn based on the above:

·         SPF # 1 related to the accelerated development of backward areas as well as planned development of the capital.
·         Paragraphs 1 through 4 of the October 1973 clarification statement relate to the first leg of SPF # 1 i.e. accelerated development of backward areas
·         Paragraph 5 of clarification statement relates to the second leg i.e. planned development of the capital
·         None of the other five SPF points or the clarification statement paragraphs relate to the development of either backward areas or the capital

Satya in effect quotes paragraph 5 of the October 1973, not the presidential order. Dismissing his contention on this technical ground is, however, unreasonable and frivolous.

Further examination

It is clear SPF # 1 did not receive any legislative support unlike the other five points that were acted upon. This may be because it was believed this principle could be established through executive action.

I am also unable to find any evidence of mechanisms to implement SPF # 1. Schemes as well as Capital Development Authority referred by clarification # 5 do not appear to have taken off. This may however not be a deterrent if executive action is adequate to implement the principle.

As SPF 2-6 are outside the present debate, I decided to ignore the following questions:

·         Were SPF 2-5 effectively implemented?
·         If yes, did they achieve the intended objective?
·         Do the results justify the scrapping of Mulki rules & regional committees as per SPF 6?
·         Will Telangana formation invalidate article 371 D in so far as it pertains to the new state?
·         If it does, are Mulki rules reinstated as on the appointed date?

I am also not concerned about the benefit if any received through SPF # 1. It is probable that the first (and arguably more important) leg of SPF # 1 was never implemented earnestly. I limit myself to the implementation, if any, of the second leg i.e. development of the capital.

I spent time looking up the central institutions located in and around Hyderabad. The results sorted by the starting date (or the date of shifting to Hyderabad) are as follows:

·         Praga Tools (1943)
·         NPA (1956)
·         NIN (1958)
·         DLRL (1961)
·         DRDL (1962)
·         BHEL (1963)
·         DMRL (1963)
·         HMT (1965)
·         HAL (1965)
·         ECIL (1967)
·         IDPL (1967)
·         NFC (1971)
·         Dundigul AFA (1971)
·         HCL (1972)
·         NRSC (1974)
·         CCMB (1977)
·         CMC (1982)
·         RCI (1985)
·         BEL (1986)

Conclusions

The presidential ordinance is dated 1975. However as our frame of reference is the statement of September 21, 1973, it is a good idea to treat 1974 as the cut-off date.

The first 14 institutions were started on or before 1972. They are therefore related to SPF # 1.

The next three (HCL, NRSC & CCMB) look to be based on SPF # 1.

I am not too sure about CMC (1982). Computers were still a novelty back then. CMC has since been privatized.

I strongly suspect RCI was setup as a logical consequence to the establishment of three other DRDO laboratories. The same may apply to the BEL vs. ECIL situation. In any case, the license-quota raj was slowly coming to an end.

I did not include HCU (1974) above as it clearly falls under SPF # 2. I also excluded Ordnance Factory (1984) as I deem it to be a result of Indira Gandhi's Medak election promises.

What do the results show? Three (or perhaps four if you include CMC) of the central establishments in and around Hyderabad can be linked to the SPF # 1. The others constituting the vast majority are clearly unrelated.

Did the others come to Hyderabad because it was the capital? I do not believe so. In any case, these are outside the scope of this post.


Did I miss any others? Please let me know if I did and I will gladly reassess.